By Seb Joseph and Kayleigh Barber • September 30, 2024 •
<img width="1030" height="579" src="https://digiday.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2024/09/google-scales-digiday.png?w=1030&h=579&crop=1" alt decoding="async" fetchpriority="high"/>
Ivy Liu
With the antitrust trial against Google’s alleged ad monopoly space to wrap by year’s quit, the trade buzz has shifted to the fallout. Will Google’s ad empire regain dismantled? And if that’s the case, will or not it is a clean break or suitable a few free threads? Maybe Google will suitable be slapped with a hefty handsome.
For publishers, the stakes are high — this hits shut to residence. At the back of closed doors, some are nervously biting their nails, worried that lawmakers could actually observe via on breaking up the tech giant.
Make no mistake — they’re hungry for change. After nearly two decades of residing beneath Google’s thumb, they’re savoring the watch of the tech giant sweating beneath the legal microscope.
However a breakup? That’s flirting with disaster — for them, anyway.
Here’s why: If the Department of Justice proves Google built an illegal ad monopoly and the courts back a breakup of the promote-aspect of its trade, publishers could take a major hit. They’re worried the programmatic ad dollars they rely on could dry up — a stamp they’re not willing to pay.
“As long as Google has the aquire-aspect of its ads trade nothing goes to change — and that’s the part of the trade they’ll by no means stop,” said the head of digital at a publisher who spoke on situation of anonymity.
To understand why publishers are sweating over what could regain spun off, it is a must to know how Google’s ad empire really works. Google controls the greatest pool of online ad dollars, primarily via its DV360 and Google Ads platforms. For publishers to tap into that cash, they have to promote via Google’s AdX marketplace—and that requires using Google’s ad server. If Google is forced to lower ties with both, publishers could lose access to those critical dollars, as DV360 and Google Ads would probably remain with whichever part of Google holds on to them.
Information Corp obtained a wake-up call on this back in 2017. Ad pros there determined to test the waters by switching ad servers, which lower them off from the AdX programmatic marketplace — and the advertisers using Google’s platform to aquire from it. The worth tag for that experiment? A hefty $9 million in lost ad earnings.
When this bombshell came up in the trial’s first week, it greatest confirmed what many publishers had been quietly fearing all along.
“Every publisher I’ve spoken to about this case has voiced some challenge to me about the final end result of the trial being spinning that Google sells off the promote-aspect of its ads trade,” said an ad tech exec, who exchanged anonymity for candor.
One publisher didn’t mince words, going even further: “The probability that Google’s ad trade gets dismantled as a outcomes of the trial … I really feel it’s low. It’s extraordinarily complicated, but by way of the final end result of things, it’s one thing that we’d have to resolve out,” they said.
Because let’s face it — disruption is inevitable. The real wildcard for publishers isn’t Google’s fate — it’s how a lot the relaxation of the trade gets burned in the process.
“A end result that fails to mosey out DV360 misses the point,” said David Kohl, CEO of Symitri (the ad exchange formerly owned by publisher trade organization DCN known as TRUSTX). “The total ad tech trade must be made impartial if we’re to witness any material change for commence-web publishers. An impartial SSP and ad server is greatest a partial resolve.”
What these publishers are saying isn’t engaging — it’s a general refrain across the trade. However their reluctance to break up Google’s ad trade, despite being the ones most afflict by it, speaks volumes. It’s as in the occasion that they’re in a co-dependent bind — what they want to escape is the very thing they can’t dwell without. And the silence from so many greatest highlights suitable how conflicted they really are.
Ironically, essentially the most vocal scream on the topic has reach from the varied aspect of the market — The Trade Desk’s CEO Jeff Inexperienced. Speaking on stage at Exchangewire’s ATS convention earlier this month, he mused over the complexity of unraveling Google’s promote-aspect, calling it “extraordinarily complicated because it’s so integrated.”
However if it were to happen, in Inexperienced’s gape, DV360 would merely pivot to monetizing Google’s search and YouTube companies, which, in the quit, could actually aid Google’s interests suitable handsome.
Adding gasoline to this theory is the fact that Google has already dangled the idea of marketing the AdX marketplace,